About

Discerning Citizen

HomeIssuesLinksReadingNewsletters

 

Home > Issues > Economy > Record Dow Not As Good As It Seems

 

Record Dow Not As Good As It Seems

Posted May 7, 2007

By M. Roberts

   The Dow Jones Industrial average closed Friday at 13,264.62 - another record high. According to CNN, Friday’s session made this the longest bull run in 80 years.  The Dow has now risen in 23 of the last 26 sessions, marking its longest bull run since the summer of 1927, when the indicator ended higher in 24 of 27 sessions”, reported CNN. 1 As investors cheer, it is worth noting that the numbers are not as great as they sound. The Dow may be hitting new records, but believe it or not, it has actually been a losing investment since the end of the 1990s. Yes, that’s right. If you had invested your money in the companies composing the Dow in 2000, your investments probably gained in dollar terms but they have lost purchasing power. Your investment dollars buy less today than they did in 2000. The reason? Inflation.

   The best way to measure wealth is in terms of purchasing power, not dollars. One may have more dollars, but if it takes significantly more of them to purchase the same things, one cannot necessarily be considered wealthier. Take for instance gasoline prices, which have doubled since 2000. 2 Unless the average American’s income has doubled over the last 7 years, it is a pretty safe bet that a larger percentage of the monthly budget is going to gasoline. This is also true for other expenses, such as housing, insurance, and food. Dollars just aren’t going as far as they once did. If inflation is driving up prices faster than wages, people are getting poorer because their money is losing purchasing power. The main culprit behind inflation today is the rapid expansion of the money supply by the Federal Reserve. Every dollar added to the money supply devalues every other dollar in circulation, and the money supply has nearly doubled in just the last 10 years to nearly $10 trillion today. 3 With so much money supply expansion, it is no surprise that inflation is seriously eroding the purchasing power of the dollar. The Dow may be hitting new records, but the picture looks significantly different when inflation is taken into account. 

 

 

Figure 1. Gold prices show that the Dow peaked around 2000 and has been declining ever since. Dow represented by annual closing value. Gold represented by annual London afternoon spot gold closing price. Source: CNN Money (Dow Jones Data) and www.onlygold.com (Spot Gold Prices).

   The best benchmark to measure the impact of inflation is the price of gold. Anybody that watches the price of gold knows that it has increased significantly over recent years, climbing from about $270/oz at the end of 2000 to nearly $700/oz today. This increase is not because gold has gained in value, but because inflation has eroded the purchasing power of the dollar. The value of gold is largely static; an ounce of gold buys about the same basket of goods today that it did 100 years ago. This remarkable stability is the reason it serves as a good benchmark to measure the value of other things, such as the dollar and investments denominated in dollars. Despite continually hitting new records, gold prices show that the purchasing power of investments in the Dow peaked around 2000 and have been declining ever since. As Figure 1 shows, it took about 43 ounces of gold to buy the Dow in 2000 and it only takes 19 ounces of gold to buy it today. 

   The media can hype the record closings of the Dow all they want, but the numbers speak for themselves. The Dow may be worth more dollars than ever, but inflation shows a Dow in decline.

1. Dow: Longest Bull Run in 80 Years, (May 4, 2007). Retrieved May 7, 2007, from http://money.cnn.com/2007/05/04/markets/markets_0530/index.htm?postversion=2007050417
2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Indexes. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Retrieved May 7, 2007, from http://www.bls.gov/cpi/
3. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis M3 and Components. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Retrieved May 7, 2007, from http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/categories/28
^ Top

 

Copyright © 2005, 2006, 2007 Discerning Citizen. All rights reserved.

Email the webmaster with comments on the site design.

Photos courtesy of freefoto.com.